Dichotomous Understandings of Gender and Sexuality.

Historically speaking, concepts of gender, sex, and sexuality have been interrelated and defined in strictly binary terms. One would be characterized as either male or female, as strictly defined by one’s reproductive organs. The male or female individual would be sexually interested in either the opposite or same gender and would thus be afforded a label of heterosexual or homosexual. They would be expected to conform to social concepts of “masculinity,” “femininity,” “straightness,” or “queerness.” While cultural variations exist in how these concepts are defined, it remains that they are generally rigidly upheld as dichotomous and opposite in Western Eurocentric societies.

The rigidity of such gender role concepts was explored in class through the discussion of gendered toys and tacit implication that one’s enjoyment of a toy is inherently connected to one’s gender. While boys are expected to enjoy toys that reflect traditionally masculine concepts of toughness, stoicism, and courage; girls are expected to enjoy toys that reflect traditionally feminine concepts of nurturance, passivity, empathy, and modesty. Bonus points if the toys are colour-coded into pink or blue.

Interestingly, should a child deviate from their traditional gender-assigned toy category of choice, reactions are sure to vary: A small girl playing with trucks and superheroes might be praised as feisty or strong, while a small boy playing with dolls is more likely to be dissuaded from such interests. This is an example of hegemonic masculinity and serves to justify the dominance of the emphasized masculine performing male population over women, girls, and non-traditionally masculine performing boys and men.

These rigid binary considerations of gender are deeply problematic for the vast numbers of human beings who do not necessarily conform to expectations. As Susanne Luhmann explains, “Girls and boys and women and men who don’t fit the stereotypes associated with their gender face near daily homophobic name calling…and all too often, physical violence, not only from their peers but also, too frequently, from their own families.” (Luhmann, 2017, p. 125)

As we are coming to understand, gender and sexuality are social constructs that exist on a spectrum. Gender exists independently of sexual organs and is performed according to social cues that have been codified to broadcast masculinity or femininity. With gender established as a social construct, it follows that sexuality is far more complex than “gay” or “straight.” Spectrums of gender and sexuality, further complicated by the consideration of intersex bodies, are robustly explored in Queer theory. Queer theorists “[recognize] the separation of biological sex from gender and from sexuality. This has allowed feminists to contemplate multiple and complex identities.” (Bromley, 2012, p. 99).

In establishing that the traditional dichotomous understanding of gender, sex, and sexuality is misconceived, it becomes prudent to adjust to “move beyond,” as Siltanen & Doucet suggest. Beyond simply being erroneous, upholding these misconceptions can result in measurable psychological and physical harm to individuals who deviate from the norm, as Luhmann noted. From a strictly academic perspective, they do not reflect an accurate or practical view of the intricacies of human society, and as such are neither productive nor appropriate.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ethical Suffrage: Canadian Offenders and the Right to Vote

              Ethical Suffrage: Canadian Offenders and the Right to Vote             Political Science 2200 – 001 Douglas College Dayna Wilson 300113188 19   November 2021 Word Count: 1425   When the Supreme Court of Canada decided in 2002 that barring prisoners from voting violated their constitutional right to democratic participation, the news was met with much opposition. Victims’ rights advocates were vocal about their outrage, including Gary Rosenfeldt who told CBC news “These are people who flagrantly disobeyed the laws of this country, who don't care about the laws of this country” (CBC 2004). The 2004 federal election saw Conservatives running on a platform that included a vow to “forbid prisoners in federal institutions from voting in elections” (Conservative Party of Canada 2004). Despite such opposition, it remains the case that not only is universal suffrage enshrined in the Charter of Canadian Rights and Freedoms , but it empirica
Read more

The Exploitation of the #BossBabe: Multi-level Marketing Schemes and Gender Roles

          The Exploitation of the #BossBabe: Multi-level Marketing Schemes and Gender Roles               Dayna Wilson – 300113188 SOCI 1125 – 005: Introduction to Sociology Dr. Siobhan Ashe Douglas College 13 December, 2021 Word Count: 1431       When the multi-level marketing (MLM) scheme was initially ideated in the 1930s with Avon (then California Perfume Company), it afforded women the opportunity to make money independently of the allowances designated to them by their husbands, as was the norm at the time. This allowed women to gain a modicum of freedom previously unrealized and opened doors of female empowerment. A century later, however, the model and its outcomes have undoubtedly shifted. MLMs, which are characterized by person-to-person sales and the recruitment of fellow distributors, tend to disproportionately target women and exploit gender inequality. This frequently leads to the further marginalization of an already vulnerable p
Read more

A Bad Joke: Credibility and the Flat Earth Society

  Dayna Wilson Written for ENGL 1130 – 103 Douglas College / Dr. Noelle Phillips, PhD   A Bad Joke: Credibility and the Flat Earth Society The Flat Earth Society (FES) has taken pains to appear on their website as a credible, science-based organization. In the ‘about’ column on the front page of the site, they purport to be “a place for free thinkers and the intellectual exchange of ideas” (The Flat Earth Society 2020). The visually appealing and easily navigable page links to an incredibly detailed Wiki, where curious first-time viewers are encouraged to begin their exploration of FES theories and “evidence.” Everything within the wiki appears to be well written and with plenty of citations, just as one would expect in a reputable mainstream site. On the surface, nothing serves to immediately trigger one to the fact that they have stumbled onto anything less than completely legitimate. Once one takes the time to analyse the content of the site in depth, however, it becomes cle
Read more